A few days ago, I wrote about first basemen the Cubs could potentially target once Derrek Lee’s contract expires at the end of this season. In a nutshell, I looked at potential free agents Albert Pujols, Lance Berkman, and Adam Dunn. My conclusion? If Pujols is available, you spend what you have to spend to get him. I also said I didn’t see any possible way he would be available. The Cards have an option on Pujols for 2011 which they are sure to exercise.
The other two first basemen available via free agency simply don’t fit the bill for the Cubs. They would be better off re-signing Derrek Lee rather than pursue Berkman. They are similar players, although Lee is the superior fielder. Dunn could really help the Cubs offense, but I don’t think the team should give up the defense it would take to get that offense.
Then I turned my attention to the trade market. The two players potentially available via trade that I discussed were San Diego’s Adrian Gonzalez and Minnesota’s Justin Morneau. I honestly don’t know if the Cubs have the players it would take to make either of these trades, but I think it is worth investigating.
What I didn’t mention in the previous post is that the Cubs have some internal candidates they are going to have to look at to determine who will be playing first base for the team in the future.
First on the list is the incumbent, Derrek Lee. Lee is currently 35-years old and his slow start to the 2010 season may be an indication that age is starting to catch up with him. I wouldn’t bet my life on it, but it could be. Despite Lee’s offensive production during his time with the Cubs and his great defense, it seems to me that the Cubs should move in a different direction. He may have a couple of good years left in him, but two good years on a four or five year contract is not a good deal.
Another candidate for first base is current left fielder Alfonso Soriano. I’m fairly certain that moving Soriano to first base would not be the Cubs preferred choice, but it may turn into a necessity. Soriano has already showed signs of slowing down in the outfield and his defensive ability in left seems to have regressed this year. And remember, Soriano started his career as a second baseman. He wasn’t a particularly good second baseman, but first base does not require the same level of foot work and dexterity that is required of a middle infielder.
It’s also important to remember that Soriano has five years left on a virtually untradeable contract. He’ll be around for another four years beginning in 2011 making $18 million per year, so the Cubs have to figure out what to do with him. With a possible opening at first base in 2011, Soriano may become the Cubs first baseman of the future.
Aramis Ramirez is another player the Cubs might consider for first base. Of course, that assumes that Ramirez either doesn’t opt out of his contract at the end of this season, or if he does, that the Cubs can re-sign him. If he is still with the club in 2011, the Cubs might consider moving him to first base in order to give highly touted prospect Josh Vitters an opening at third.
On the other hand, perhaps Vitters, who has struggled with the glove at third, could be converted into a first baseman. There has been a lot of talk about moving Vitters to a different position, so maybe he’ll end up at first. Another option is for Vitters to move to left field, a position that could be open if Soriano is moved to first.
Finally, the only prospect the Cubs currently have in the minors that is considered a first baseman is Micah Hoffpauir. He’s not a flashy candidate, but he is cheap. My own opinion is that Hoffpauir does not have a future with the Cubs. He’s out of minor league options following this season and I don’t see him coming back with the Cubs in 2011. However, if the Cubs decide to save money on first base next year and spend it elsewhere (or not spend it at all), Hoffpauir is one in-house candidate that is also inexpensive.
The 2011 season is too far away to make any real educated predictions about who might end up at first base for the Cubs. But it does seem likely that change will be afoot and the Cubs will have a new first baseman next year. Who that will be is anybody’s guess.


